This month I asked three experts in healthcare and technology, about the potential pitfalls and opportunities presented by the adoption of digital passports in healthcare.
Michael ‘Dersh’ Dershem, Founder and CEO at MAPay
A medical passport, also known as a health passport or health certificate, is a document that contains an individual’s medical history, vaccinations and other pertinent health information.
Here are some pros and cons associated with medical passports.
Pros:
- Convenient access to medical information: Medical passports allow individuals to have easy access to their medical history, which can be particularly useful when seeking healthcare in different locations or when dealing with emergencies.
- Facilitates travel: Medical passports can streamline the process of travelling, especially to countries with strict health requirements or during health crises such as pandemics. They can provide proof of vaccination status and other relevant health information necessary for entry into certain countries.
- Improved healthcare coordination: Medical passports can enhance communication and coordination among healthcare providers by ensuring that all relevant medical information is readily available. This can lead to more informed and efficient healthcare decisions.
- Enhanced privacy and security: Depending on the system used, medical passports may offer secure storage and encryption of health data, providing better privacy protection compared to traditional paper records.
Cons:
- Privacy concerns: While medical passports offer the convenience of accessing health information, they also raise concerns about privacy and data security. There’s a risk that sensitive health information could be accessed or exploited if the system is not adequately secured.
- Digital divide: Not everyone has equal access to technology or the internet, which could exclude certain populations from using digital medical passports effectively. This may exacerbate existing disparities in healthcare access and outcomes.
- Potential for misuse or fraud: Like any digital document, medical passports could be subject to hacking, forgery or other forms of misuse. Unauthorised access or manipulation of health information could have serious consequences for individuals’ health and privacy.
- Standardisation challenges: Establishing standardised formats and protocols for medical passports can be challenging, especially on a global scale. Without uniform standards, interoperability between different systems and healthcare providers may be limited.
- Ethical considerations: There are ethical considerations surrounding the use of medical passports, including issues related to consent, autonomy and equity. It’s important to address these concerns to ensure that the implementation of medical passports is fair and respects individuals’ rights.
Overall, while medical passports have the potential to improve healthcare coordination and facilitate travel, they also pose challenges related to privacy, security, equity and ethics that need to be carefully addressed.
Randy Boldyga, Founder, CEO, and President at RXNT
Digital health passports offer something people care about more than ever—convenience. That’s incredibly valuable in an increasingly global dynamic of travel and commerce. With the prevalence of smartphones, many individuals have constant access to their digital devices, making digital health records a simple option compared to carrying around paper documents. This convenience extends beyond personal ease to societal benefits. That was particularly evident during the COVID-19 pandemic, where digital passports helped facilitate safer travel and expedited entry processes, minimising potential virus transmission risks. The pandemic underscored the importance of modern, agile solutions that meet the public’s needs amidst rapidly changing circumstances, and digital health passports emerged as a clear success story.
However, as with any technological advancement, convenience usually comes with potential trade-offs. The most obvious concern with digital health passports is around data privacy and security, as the reliance on any digital platform for healthcare purposes requires users to share sensitive personal information that could potentially be compromised. Obviously, that means any digital health passport product or solution needs to be built with security as the number one concern. Building public trust is essential in addressing apprehensions and encouraging widespread adoption. It needs to be made incredibly clear what efforts have gone into making them a safe tool, and how users can help protect their own information.
The digital divide is also worth noting here. Varying levels of access to and familiarity with tech creates significant concerns around equitable access. Older adults, who are more likely to lack trust in new technology and are also significantly less likely to own smartphones, are particularly at risk of being excluded from the benefits of digital health passports. For the time being, it’s crucial to maintain traditional methods of health record verification—but we also need to make sure digital options aren’t being ignored because they’re potentially more complex or expensive to implement. The coexistence of traditional and digital methods is key to ensure inclusivity and accessibility for the majority of the public.
On a broader level, there are also major technical and regulatory challenges to navigate. Ensuring the standardisation and interoperability of digital health passport systems across different regions and jurisdictions is not a simple task. Accomplishing a standard digital system would be a major international project involving hundreds of software engineers, politicians, regulators and cybersecurity experts. Laws around digital privacy and safety differ greatly between the US and European Union, for example—and that only becomes more sensitive when personal health information is involved.
Henry Criss, CEO at Fraum Center for Restorative Health
The integration of digital passports into healthcare systems is a major step forward in the use of modern technology to enhance patient care, streamline operations, and strengthen data security. One of the biggest opportunities presented by the incorporation of digital passports is improved patient access and convenience. These digital tools allow individuals to effortlessly access their medical histories, including critical information such as vaccinations, lab results and documented medical conditions, from anywhere at any time. This not only improves patient engagement with their health management but also ensures a more informed healthcare experience overall. Additionally, the adoption of digital passports will bolster data security through the implementation of advanced encryption and data protection measures, offering a more secure alternative to traditional paper-based records and thereby mitigating the risk of data breaches. Digital passports promise to streamline healthcare operations by providing a uniform method for the exchange of health information, thereby reducing administrative burdens, and facilitating more efficient patient care coordination. They also stand to support public health initiatives, particularly in managing health crises by enabling efficient verification of individuals’ health status, which is crucial for safe travel and economic reopening in the face of pandemics.
However, the shift towards digitalisation in healthcare is not without its pitfalls. Privacy concerns are at the forefront, with the centralisation of sensitive health information posing a risk of potential misuse if not adequately protected. This could lead to significant privacy violations and erode public trust in digital health initiatives. Additionally, the move towards digital health solutions might worsen existing healthcare disparities due to the digital divide, leaving those without access to necessary technology at a disadvantage. Interoperability challenges also pose a significant barrier to the seamless exchange of health data across different healthcare systems and jurisdictions, potentially undermining the efficiency and utility of digital passports. Additionally, navigating the complex regulatory landscape and addressing ethical considerations related to consent, data sharing, and discrimination are paramount to ensuring the successful implementation of digital passports in a manner that aligns with ethical standards and respects patient rights.
While digital passports in healthcare represent a promising shift towards more efficient, secure, and patient-centered care, it will be important to address the accompanying challenges through collaborative efforts among technology developers, healthcare providers, policymakers, and patients. By prioritising privacy, equity and interoperability, the healthcare sector can leverage the benefits of digital passports to the fullest while mitigating potential drawbacks.
Click below to share this article